Observation Is More Than Watching
Evidence-First™ Series | Part 2 of 10
A classroom may generate hundreds of observable interactions during a single lesson. Yet an evaluator or instructional coach must decide, in real time, what matters, what to record, what those events mean, how they connect to an educator observation framework, and what rating they may eventually support.
We tend to call all of this observation. But it is actually a series of rapid cognitive decisions. Each step requires professional expertise. The challenge is that evaluators often perform many of these tasks almost simultaneously. Research on rubric-based observation has similarly highlighted the complexity of moving from classroom events to professional judgment (Gore & Rickard, 2024).

When Too Many Judgments Happen at Once
Moersch and Saunders (2026) refer to this rapid merging of observation, interpretation, evaluation, and recommendation as cognitive compression. Compression can create several problems. For example, two evaluators may:
Notice different events,
Notice the same event but interpret it differently, or
Agree about what happened but apply the rubric differently.
Yet the final evaluation report may show only:
Evaluator A: 3 (Effective/Proficient)
Evaluator B: 4 (Highly Effective/Distinguished)
The score tells us that disagreement occurred. It does not tell us where the disagreement began.
The Issue Is Not Lack of Expertise
This should not be interpreted as a criticism of principals, supervisors, or EPP evaluators. Experienced observers often make professional judgments quickly because they have developed strong mental models of effective instruction. That expertise is valuable. The problem is that the reasoning process can become so compressed that it is difficult to examine. An evaluator may move almost instantly from: “I saw this…” to “This means…” to “Therefore, this lesson is…”
The challenge may not be that evaluators lack expertise. The challenge may be that we ask them to use too much of that expertise simultaneously.
Creating More Space Between Seeing and Judging
Evidence-First™ addresses cognitive compression by creating greater separation between what was observed and how it is interpreted.
Rather than moving immediately from classroom events to rubric conclusions, the evaluator first establishes observable evidence using evidence markers. Interpretation and formal scoring occur afterward.
The goal is not to eliminate professional judgment. It is to make that judgment more transparent and disciplined so that school districts and EPP’s can better understand where agreement exists, where disagreement begins, and why.
Challenge: Cognitive Compression Self-Check
During a classroom observation, which of the following do you find yourself doing subconsciously while recording notes?
☐ Deciding what to pay attention to
☐ Choosing what to record
☐ Interpreting what an instructional event means
☐ Mentally connecting evidence to a rubric category
☐ Estimating a final performance level
☐ Thinking about feedback or next steps for the teacher/candidate
☐ None of the above
If you checked several of these boxes, you're not alone. These mental processes are a natural part of classroom observation, and each plays an important role in evaluating instructional practice. The challenge arises when we perform them simultaneously, allowing our interpretations and expectations to influence what we notice and record before we've fully established the evidence. This is where cognitive compression can affect the consistency and transparency of observations.
Evidence-First™ encourages a more deliberate approach: first recognize and document what actually happened, then interpret that evidence, connect it to professional standards, and determine what it tells us about instructional practice. By separating these steps, observers can make better use of their professional expertise while producing more consistent, defensible, and growth-focused feedback.
References
Gore, J., & Rickard, K. (2024). How might rubric-based observations better support teacher development? Educational Research, 66(1), 45–62.
Moersch, C., & Saunders, D. (2026). Observation before interpretation: An Evidence-First™ methodology for professional practice. LoTi Connection.




Comments